Saturday, November 01, 2008

Finnish Voting Machines Slated by Usability Experts

Voting systems lack usability worldwide ...

"The U.S. isn't the only country where electronic voting machines are causing problems. Usability experts have some harsh words about Finnish voting machines, which where trialed in municipal elections on Sunday and caused about 200 lost votes.

Voters had trouble using the touchscreen-based voting terminal, according to the Finnish Justice Department. Out of 12,234 voters, 232 didn't finish the voting process properly, resulting in their votes not being cast.

The Finnish terminal required voters to first insert a smart card for identification, type in a candidate number, then press the "OK" button, check the candidate details on the following page, then press "OK" a second time to validate the vote, and remove the smart card. But the voters who failed didn't go through the whole process, according to the Finnish Justice Department.

The decision by the designers to use two different pages, for first casting the vote and then validating it, is blamed for the problems by usability experts.

When the voter is in the voting booth, and in a hurry, he or she can believe that the voting is done when the "OK" button has been pressed for the first time, because of how the system was designed, according to Jeanin Day, interaction architect at Antrop.

Teresa Colombi, CTO of ergonomics consultancy LudoTIC, agrees. "The system lacks guidance, one of the qualities necessary to ensure usability," she said.

A specific message, after the voter has clicked on the "OK" button the first time, could tell the voter that their vote is being processed and that they must wait until the following step before removing their card, according to Colombi. That could prevent the user from leaving the voting booth before the vote is cast.

But that isn't the only problem: The "OK" button also moves from right to left between the two pages. Moving buttons that do the same thing is a big no-no when designing user interfaces, according to Zayera Khan, design strategist at inUse.

"There is a lot that has to be improved before the system can be used on a larger scale," said Khan."    (Continued via PC World, Mikael Rickn√§s)    [Ergonomics Resources]

Listen to this article


Post a Comment